Journal of Special Education and Rehabilitation

Frequency: quarterly
ISSN: 1409-6099 (Print)
ISSN: 1857-663X (Online)

Download reviewer form:
	Word PDF

Journal of
Special
Education and
Rehabilitation

Review Form

MANUSCRIPT TITLE:

AUTHOR(S):

Please mark “X” according to your criteria.

WHAT TYPE OF PAPER IS IT?

	Yes	No
Trick/Hack
Original Technique/Algorithm
Novel Research Idea
Experience/Advice
Survey
Tutorial
Production Notes

SCOPE OF THE WORK

	Yes	No
1. The topic is appropriate for publication in JOURNAL OF SPECIAL EDUCATION AND REHABILITATION
2. The title correctly describes the topic, the latter is treated appropriately.
3. The abstract accurately reflects the content.
4. The purpose or thesis of the article is stated clearly.
5. The purported significance of the article is explicitly stated.
6. The article adequately ties to the relevant literature.

SCIENTIFIC QUALITY

	Yes	No
7. The work is original and creative.
8. The work contributes to new knowledge in Special Educational Sciences.
9. There is coherency among the problem addressed, the method used, the results presented, and the conclusions.
10. The research study methods are sound and appropriate.
11. The literature review and research study methods are explained clearly.
12. The primary thesis is argued persuasively.

STYLE AND FORMAT

	Yes	No
13. The work is well organized.
14. The writing is clear concise and interesting.
15. Structure and grammar are good.
16. Figures, photos and tables are of good quality and appropriate for the work.
17. The conclusions or summary are accurate and supported by the content.

FINAL RECOMMENDATION
Do you recommend that the work:

	Yes	No
Be accepted in its present form
Be accepted after moderate style and format changes
Be accepted after major style and format changes
Be accepted after moderate fundamental changes
Be accepted after major fundamental changes
Be rejected